When Jim Kowalski bought his ’69 GTO Judge new, he knew it was a keeper but couldn’t imagine it would still be handing down high-performance justice more than 40 years later.

“My ’64 GTO convertible was totaled by a drunk driver in 1969, and the accident put me in the market for a new Pontiac,” Jim recalls. “A friend of mine had a new Judge and it really impressed me, so I immediately started looking for one.” After visiting three dealerships—one wanted to sell him a Verdoro Green Ram Air IV GTO, but he passed—Jim found a Carousel Red Ram Air III Judge on the new car lot of Coe-Hayden Motors in Ionia, Michigan. It was the only Judge at the dealership that day.

“It had 17 or so miles on it,” Jim says. “I fell in love with it.”

For a lot car, the Judge had every performance option Jim would have picked if he had special ordered it. The 366hp Ram Air III 400 and 3.55 gears came standard, and the Muncie four-speed, front disc brakes, Safe-T-Track, Rally gauges and clock, and hood-mounted tachometer were popular extra-cost performance items.

“The price was $3,900 including tax, tag, and a full tank of gas,” he continues. “I put down a $1,300 cash deposit (all in hundred-dollar bills) on June 6, 1969, and came back the next day with 26 more hundred-dollar bills and drove it home.”

When he got there, Jim’s dad, Leonard (an Oldsmobile employee who drove a new company car every two years), offered to give up the family’s one-car garage so that the Judge wouldn’t see rain or snow. “He thought it was so cool,” Jim says.

Soon thereafter, Jim treated his Judge to some of the popular aftermarket bolt-ons of the day—Anson Sprint aluminum slots, wide and beefy bias-ply tires, spring spacers, and air shocks. He even installed a Ram Air IV intake manifold. Since he worked at Lansing Plating, he chromed many of the engine-bay items, too: the upper Ram Air pan, air cleaner, breather tube, belt-drive pulleys, alternator, engine hoist hook, dipstick pull, heater core cover, master cylinder and brake booster, hoodspring, hood hinges, and more.

Jim had a favorite Friday and Saturday night cruise spot—Lansing, Michigan’s Washington Avenue—that he and his friends affectionately called “The Gut.” While Jim’s friends lived by the motto, “Break it in hard from new, drive it fast, and expect it to have a short life,” Jim took the high road. “I don’t remember racing it much,” he says. “Other guys street raced every weekend, but I loved the Judge and babied it. I wanted it to have a long life.”

In 1970, the Judge took on a new role. “I married and it became the family car,” he says. Six years and two kids later, his father gave him a ’70 Oldsmobile, and Jim retired John DeLorean’s flamboyant limited-edition musclecar to a weekend cruiser.

He says the next chapter in the Judge’s story started in 1986, when he pulled and bagged the original 400, installed a ’67 400 and straight dumps, and began taking the Judge to car shows. “I didn’t realize how popular—or iconic—the Judge had become in all those years,” he says.

In 2010, he reinstalled the original long-block, and asked Scott Tiemann of Supercar Specialties to give his Judge a budget restoration, focusing primarily on exterior rust repair and new paint. “The rust wasn’t that bad for a Michigan car,” Scott says. “You can tell it spent most of its life in a garage.”